The Great Debate: Vegetable Oil vs Shortening in Mochi Donuts

The Great Debate: Vegetable Oil vs Shortening in Mochi Donuts

Mochi donuts, with their chewy and soft texture, have taken the dessert world by storm. As the delightful fusion of Japanese mochi and American donuts, they offer a unique treat that appeals to dessert enthusiasts everywhere. When it comes to making these delectable treats, the choice of fat used in the recipe can significantly impact the taste, texture, and overall experience of the mochi donuts. In this blog, we delve into the great debate: vegetable oil vs. shortening in mochi donuts, and explore how each option influences these beloved treats.

1. Vegetable Oil: Light and Versatile Pros:

  • Light Texture: Using vegetable oil in mochi donuts can result in a lighter and airier texture. The oil's ability to create tiny air pockets during the mixing process contributes to a less dense final product, making the donuts feel more delicate on the palate.
  • Moisture Retention: Vegetable oil has a higher moisture content compared to shortening, which helps keep the mochi donuts moist and tender, even after a few days.
  • Convenience: Vegetable oil is readily available in most households and easy to incorporate into the mochi donut recipe. It eliminates the need for specialized equipment or extra steps, simplifying the preparation process.


  • Milder Flavor: Vegetable oil has a neutral flavor profile, which can result in mochi donuts with a less pronounced taste. If you're looking for a bolder flavor, you may need to rely on other flavoring agents like extracts or spices.

2. Shortening: For a Rich and Tender Indulgence Pros:

  • Richness and Flavor: Shortening has a distinct buttery flavor that can impart a rich and indulgent taste to mochi donuts. It enhances the overall depth of flavor and provides a comforting experience with every bite.
  • Tender Texture: When used in mochi donuts, shortening contributes to a tender and soft texture. The donuts may be slightly denser, but they are still delightfully chewy and satisfying.
  • Stability: Shortening has a higher melting point than vegetable oil, which can help the mochi donuts maintain their shape during frying and prevent excessive spreading.


  • Less Moisture: Shortening contains less moisture compared to vegetable oil, which can result in mochi donuts that may dry out a bit faster, especially when stored for an extended period.

Making the Choice: It's a Matter of Preference In the end, the choice between vegetable oil and shortening in mochi donuts comes down to personal preference and desired outcomes. If you're aiming for a lighter and airier texture with the convenience of readily available ingredients, vegetable oil is a great option. On the other hand, if you seek a richer and more indulgent experience with a distinct buttery taste, shortening may be the way to go.

Additionally, some bakers prefer to combine both vegetable oil and shortening in their mochi donut recipes, striking a balance between lightness and flavor. This approach allows for the best of both worlds, creating mochi donuts that are tender, moist, and boast a delightful depth of flavor.

Conclusion: The Art of Mochi Donut Making Whether you choose vegetable oil, shortening, or a combination of both, the art of making mochi donuts lies in the balance of textures, flavors, and the love poured into each batch. Embrace your creativity and experiment with different fats and flavoring agents to craft mochi donuts that cater to your unique taste preferences. The joy of mochi donuts lies not only in their delightful chewiness but also in the journey of creating these delectable treats. So, don your apron, whip up your preferred mochi donut recipe, and savor the sweet rewards of your delicious and satisfying culinary adventure. Happy baking!

Featured collection View all